After watching Born into Brothels I have to say overall I really didn't like the film all that much. Although I agree with the message the filmmakers were trying to convey, I didn't like the execution. While watching the film I really thought that they portrayed all these kids as hope less and going nowhere while the film portrayed its director, Zana Briski, as some kind of heaven sent instrument who was sent there to free these kids from the Western view point that there is nothing better than a "textbook" education.
I did find that it was effective in catching at least a glimmer of the life of a child (and the differences between the male and female children), and how instead of a research study, which at times can dehumanize people, it used advocacy art in a way of educating those who may be ignorant of the lives outside of their own urban bubbles.
The urban landscape played a dominant role within the context of the film as well. Scenes of tight winding maze-like street could be seen as a 'no-way-out' symbolism. A day trip to a beach gave the viewer as well as the children a brief sense of freedom from the confines of the district as well. I truly wonder of the meaning of the rooftops within the film as a means of escape or a bridge between the present world and a dream like state (think of Mayan upper, middle and lower level worlds analogy).
As an advocacy film for the rights of a child on a global perspective, I believe the film hit its mark. I also feel like they portrayed these kids and their families in a negative light. I am positive that these people never had dreams of becoming prostitutes, its the way life turned out, and the children seem to use apathy as a coping mechanism to deal with life and its harsh realities.
In parallel to this film (an a little closer to home) would have to be a documentary called "Streetwise". Although made in 1984, it looks into the lives of 9 young teens/children coping the streets of downtown Seattle. I will post it on here (and if you have some time, its well worth the watch.) I couldn't find part8, my apologies.
Born Into Brothels Kids Sue Filmmakers! (Calcutta newspaper, August 2008)
ReplyDeleteYes, it's true.
Born Into Brothels is a story of lies, half truths, distortions and exploitation. I invite you to read the newest blog and numerous other articles written on the hidden story behind the Hollywood-blessed "documentary." You read, you decide. It's your call.
The blog can be found at http://bornintobrothelslies.blogspot.com